Homemade Yogurt Recipe

I know many of you, like me, are always looking for ways to save money!  I confess that I kinda stink at couponing.  I am consistent at only one thing .... being inconsistent.  So I have to find creative ways to keep the grocery budget under control.  Making as many things myself that I can is one key to my success.

I have recently begun making my own yogurt, and I'm excited to tell you how so you never buy yogurt from the store again!!  This is not like baking bread or a standing rib roast!  It requires no great skill at all!  And I personally am saving almost $300 a year!

Here's what you'll need:

2 quarts of milk
A carton of plain yogurt
Quart mason jars with lids
Pot in which to heat milk
Candy/cheese thermometer
Dehydrator -- OR -- a cooler, heating pad, and towels

Ready??  Ok, a few words about ingredients here ...

Milk:  Pasteurized, raw, skim, whole ...  any kind will do, but skim will result in a runnier yogurt.  It's important to sterilize it, hence the pot and thermometer.  We'll get to that.

Yogurt:  Any plain yogurt will do as long as it has live, active cultures in it.  I prefer organic, but you can use your preference.

Um ... ok.   Milk, yogurt, um .... yep.  That's it!  Let's do it. 

Set your yogurt on the counter to let it warm a little.

Pour your 2 quarts of milk into your pot on the stove top and warm it to 180 degrees Fahrenheit.  This may take about 20 minutes or so.  Just keep rechecking every few minutes.  This is especially important if using raw milk because the bacteria in the milk (albeit healthy for you) will compete with the bacteria in the yogurt -- they don't like to share tight quarters! 

Sorry for the slightly blurry picture!  It was a challenge to take the picture quickly while turning off the stove!  :-)

**If you prefer raw yogurt, stop heating between 100 - 110 degrees F to preserve the enzymes.

Once it has reached 180 degrees, let it cool to 100-110 degrees Fahrenheit (I prefer about 100).  Leaving the jars on the counter for 1.5-3 hours will usually do the trick, depending on room temperature. 

Put 2 tablespoons of plain yogurt in each quart mason jar.  Be sure your jars are sterilized (fresh out of the dishwasher is fine).   If you choose to use raw milk without pasteurizing it, use 3 tablespoons of yogurt starter per quart of milk to give it a boost. 

After your milk has cooled, pour it into your jars and gently stir. 

Remember, these are living organisms so stirring is better than shaking.  Put your lids on, and it's time to incubate.

You can use any area that is likely to stay between 90 - 110 degrees Fahrenheit:  a hot window sill in the summer, warm car, slow cooker filled with water on low (check the temperature), etc.  Many people lay a heating pad in the bottom of a cooler, place a towel over it, and put their jars on the towel.  I've never tried this method myself, but I've read manysuccessful testimonials.

I use my dehydrator set on 100 degrees F. 

Incubation is anywhere from 4 to 24 hours.  A shorter incubation will produce a sweeter yogurt.  The longer it incubates, the more tart it becomes due to a higher culture content.  I have read, though, that after 24 hours incubating, the lactose is almost completely consumed by the bacteria, which makes the yogurt extremely digestible!  Try it a few times to determine your preference.  Don't give up if you aren't thrilled with the first results.

If you find your yogurt went too far and the whey separated out, you can either remix it or strain it with a cheese cloth for a thicker, greek-style yogurt.  If you've never seen whey separated in a cultured dairy product, here's a picture so you know what to look for.  The clear, yellowish liquid at the bottom is whey.  Don't throw it out!  It's incredibly healthy!   Just throw it in a smoothie if you don't know what else to do with it.  It's also a perfect medium for soaking your grains or beans, too.

Remember, probiotics survive freezing temperatures, so try freezing your yogurt in an ice cube tray and drop them in the blender for smoothies!  Or mix all of your yogurt in a blender with a little sugar or stevia and a splash of vanilla for store-bought taste and texture.  Any way you serve it, you're getting great probiotics and padding your wallet at the same time!  Happy incubating!

Until next time,


Pin It!


Courtney B said...

i love this! my daughter is obsessed with yogurt so i'm gonna try this!

B. Wilson @ Windy {City} Wilsons said...

I've never seen how this is done! Cool!

Stephanie @ Bellies Babies and Beyond said...

This is great! I can't wait to try it out, we go through enough yogurt this will definitely save money! Have you tried making flavored yogurt, like adding vanilla extract? I would love to know how that turned out if you have.

MammaNatty said...

I love your idea to freeze them and use them for smoothies!!


This is fantastic! I remember my mom always making her own yogurt, but I never knew how to do it! I need to do this! It will really save us a lot of money!

Sofia @ From PDX with Love said...

My mom used to make her own yogurt when we were little. I have always wanted to give it a try; never thought it was just this simple!! I would have to figure out a hot place to put the yogurt in...

Nikki said...

I've never had homemade yogurt. We eat a lot of yogurt here, though, so I'll have to try it soon!

Jennifer Clay said...

Sounds like a lot of work, but my girls love yogurt and it can get pricey after a while. I will have to try this out.

Shroff said...


amber whitehead said...

Oh wow you go girl!

Mama to 4 said...

I so need to do this, my kids data ton of yogurt, it gets expensive.

HilLesha said...

Looks good!

Post a Comment

Related Posts with Thumbnails
Design by CGM